gas cooktop and electric cooktop

Gas or Electric: Which Cooktop is Right for You?

Cooktops are the heart of the kitchen, and it can be a real bummer if they break down.   

 

If you’re considering buying a new cooktop or just trying to decide how to repair one, you might be wondering whether there are any differences between gas and electric cooktops.   

 

In this post, we’ll look at the differences between gas and electric cooktops for repair, cleaning, efficiency, safety, and more.  

 

stovetop kitchen cooking fire heat energy

 

How do gas and electric cooktops work?  

  

Gas cooktops are connected to a natural gas line or propane tank, supplying multiple burners with gas. Each burner is controlled by a knob for adjusting flame intensity and heat, ignited by an electric igniter or pilot flame.  

 

For larger families, a cooktop featuring five burners is typically more than sufficient. Brands like St George and Kleenmaid offer cooktop models equipped with 4-5 burners to accommodate a range of cooking requirements. 

 

On the other hand, there are three different types of electric cooktops. Recently, induction cooktops have also been gaining popularity, which heat up cookware directly, without coils or flames, through electromagnetic induction. 

 

Type of Cooktop  Description  Key Features  Popular Brands 
Coil Cooktops  Traditional electric stovetops with exposed coil elements  – Affordable – Durable – Direct contact heating with cookware – Basic temperature control  Westinghouse 
Electric Cooktops  Modern electric cooktops with smooth glass or ceramic surfaces  – Even heating – Easy to clean – Precise temperature control – Hidden heating elements beneath the surface  DeLonghi Electric Cooktop, Chef Electric Cooktop, Fisher & Paykel Electric Cooktop 
Induction Cooktops  Modern electric cooktops using electromagnetic induction  – Rapid and precise heating – Energy-efficient – Safety features (cool surface when not in use) – Requires magnetic cookware  Omega Induction Cooktop, Ilve Induction Cooktop, Bosch Induction Cooktop, 

Smeg Induction Cooktops 

  

induction hob modern kitchen closeup

 

Repair and Maintenace  

  

One of the most common problems with traditional gas cooktops is that the pilot light can go out. This can be caused by a draft, which can blow the flame out, or a faulty thermocouple. If the pilot light goes out, the cooktop won’t heat up. 

 

Fortunately, relighting the pilot light is usually a fairly simple process. However, if you’re not comfortable doing it yourself, hiring a skilled technician to do the job is always a safe bet.  

 

Electric cooktops are generally easier to maintain than gas cooktops. Nevertheless, they do have a separate set of maintenance requirements. 

 

One common problem with electric cooktops is that the heating element can fail. If this happens, you’ll need to replace the element. Another issue with electric cooktops can be the wiring, which can wear out over time. If you suspect that your cooktop’s wiring is faulty, it’s important to call in a professional repair technician to take a look and not try to fix it yourself as it is incredibly risky and against the law. 

 

Gas and electric cooktops each come with their own set of advantages and disadvantages. Depending on your location, electric cooktops may be a more suitable choice, while in other situations, gas cooktops could be the preferable option. We advise you to conduct thorough research on the costs of electricity and gas in your specific area before arriving at a decision. 

 

Mature housewife showing the broken stove and handyman in uniform repairing it in domestic kitchen at home

 

Cleaning  

 

When it comes to cleaning, gas cooktops often require a bit more elbow grease than electric cooktops. Gas cooktops can produce more moisture during the cooking process, which can cause grease and food particles to stick to the interior surfaces.   

 

Electric cooktops tend to be a bit drier, which can make them easier to clean. Clean your cooktop regularly to avoid build-up and damage to its interior parts, regardless of the type you have.  

 

Close-up of dirty gas cooker covered with chemical washing liquid. Housework or household chores concept.

 

Safety  

 

When it comes to cooking with gas cooktops, safety should always be top of mind. The open flame that gas cooktops produce means that keeping a safe distance between any flammable objects and the cooktop is crucial. If you ever detect a gas scent coming from your cooktop, it is important to act quickly and shut off the gas supply while seeking professional help.   

 

While electric cooktops are generally considered safer, there are still potential hazards, such as wiring issues or problems with the heating element. Put a carbon monoxide detector in your kitchen to be warned about gas leaks or combustion issues for extra safety.  

 

12% of Australian childhood asthma cases are caused by gas cooktops, which could impact your decision-making.  

 

Young man cooking meat on grill pan at home in the kitchen.

 

Energy Efficiency  

  

When it comes to choosing between gas and electric cooktops, it’s not a decision to be taken lightly. There are trade-offs to be made in terms of energy efficiency and long-term costs. Gas appliances may offer more energy-efficient performance due to the direct flame and quicker heating, but they also come with higher installation costs, which may not be feasible for everyone.   

  

Modern gas cooktops have electronic ignitions in the place of pilot lights which can reduce the cost by half when compared to an electric cooktop.  

  

On the other hand, electric appliances are often more affordable upfront, but they can have significantly higher energy consumption over time. Electric stoves and cooktops take about three times more electricity to produce and deliver when compared to gas.   

  

Consider your budget, usage patterns, and sustainability when choosing your kitchen appliances and financial goals.  

   

A woman's hand with matchstick lights gas stove in her apartment.

 

Lifespan and Durability  

  

When it comes to kitchen cooktops, durability and lifespan are important factors to consider. Choosing the right cooktop depends on whether you prefer gas or electric models. 

 

Gas cooktops often feature strong components such as stainless steel and cast iron, making them quite durable. With proper maintenance, their lifespan can be extended. However, they are also prone to common wear and tear issues such as burner and igniter replacements.   

 

On the other hand, electric cooktops rely on the quality of heating elements, electrical components and a proper installation to work efficiently. Before buying a cooktop, homeowners should consider these factors and the manufacturer’s reputation. This will help them choose a cooktop that meets their expectations and kitchen requirements.  

 

Cooker in a modern kitchen

 

Upgrading to Modern Appliances  

  

If you haven’t upgraded your appliances in a while, it’s time to consider making the switch to modern gas and electric cooktops. These appliances offer a range of advantages that can significantly enhance your cooking performance and kitchen convenience. They are more efficient, precise, and safer than their outdated counterparts. For example, brands such as Kleenmaid, Fisher & Paykel, Smeg, Omega, Ilve, Chef, Bosch and DeLonghi offer some of the more advanced cooktops in the market. Plus, they come with sleek and stylish designs that perfectly match today’s contemporary kitchen looks.   

 

Happy smiling couple just bought new household appliances in hypermarket close up

  

In conclusion, when it comes to choosing between gas and electric cooktops, there are a few factors to consider. While gas options offer precise temperature control, they require careful maintenance because of the presence of open flames. Electric cooktops are easier to maintain but may have problems with heating elements and wiring. Regardless of which option you choose, safety is key, with both types requiring attention to flammable materials.   

  

When deciding, it’s important to think about long-term costs, energy efficiency, and how long the appliance will last. By choosing the right model, you can have a safe and enjoyable cooking experience for many years. It will also improve the style and functionality of your kitchen.  

  

Need help fixing your electric or gas cooktop? Call Sydney Appliance Repair for professional support. 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *